Is it a Hall of Fame without Greavsie and Gillie?

Having read In Search of Alan Gilzean and Jimmy Greaves’ article in the People on Sunday a couple of weeks back I am left with mixed thoughts. I can understand what both men are saying about returning to White Hart Lane but something about it doesn’t sit well with me.

Both men wish to have an element of privacy and might not enjoy fans fawning over them for the duration of the visit but the facts are these are two of the greatest players alive who played for our club and they are not in our Hall of Fame.

Can this be right? I cannot believe for a moment that the Hall of Fame stands up to scrutiny without their inclusion so something needs to be done. Or does it?

It was my understanding that Jimmy disliked the dinner idea where fans pay lots of money to see their hero and get an autograph or photo but he or the players concerned get nothing at all from it. Jimmy is better off than some of his contemporaries, Alan included I would suspect, and can earn money from his fans through his stand up shows but others are not so lucky and his attitude may relate to their plight.

Alan on the other hand had stepped right out of the spotlight until James Morgan got him inducted into the Scottish Hall of Fame. In “Big Chiv” it’s made very clear that Alan is a fiercely patriotic Scot so it would have been difficult for him not to attend and accept his award. He appeared deeply moved, calling it quite rightly “the best night of his life in sport” and those in the audience would no doubt be astounded about the goal scoring feats that Craig Brown talked of in the European Cup. Click here and scroll down to see induction speech and interview

But to get him back to White Hart Lane? I have made suggestions along these lines, mainly in ignorance of his circumstances but knowing that he is so well respected that if he were down on his luck it may be a boost to him. Having learned differently by reading the book I wouldn’t want to force Gillie back into the spotlight or to force him to come face to face with his ex-colleagues if he wanted to avoid it.

But still I feel that all parties, and I include the club in this, might benefit in some small way by dealing with this Hall of Fame thing. With them out its discredited in my mind so that has to be put right but the G Men also need to accept their rightful places within that group.

I say this as we look towards building a new stadium and leaving behind their spiritual home. Walking away from the ground last Saturday it looks like some work is already ongoing behind the street façade. In the summer I visited the Camp Nou’s fantastic visitor centre and museum. Spurs have the opportunity to do something like this but if they do everyone has to be inside the tent. You cannot have the record scorer and best striker the south – if not the country –  has produced and the best header of a ball from north of the border out in the cold.

If that is the case then can a compromise not be sought? Anything is possible if communication takes place. For all we know this might be ongoing and I really hope it is.

One solution is to invite them to a game as guests of honour and make the Hall of Fame inductions at half time. In this way the club earn no extra money, the G Men are seated in the directors box and away from the limelight a little and 36,100 have the opportunity to buy a drink or watch the induction. Here everyone wins or gives the smallest amount of ground to achieve the result everybody wants – particularly us fans! 

This is no wheeling out of ancient exhibits, as Jim described it in the People, it’s two guys who were brilliant at their jobs being allowed to return to their stage for that fleeting moment to feel the warmth they once enjoyed and then to slip away never to be seen again. But if they enjoy it more than they thought they can always come visit their extended family again – I’m sure we won’t mind! 

For me Inter Milan would have been a good game but JG has a date that night so the Wolves programme told us but what about Manchester United or Arsenal or the Chelsea games? Manchester United feels right for the 5-1 victory and the roles they played in that game but those of you who saw them play a lot could probably suggest a whole host of opponents when the cameras were not present! Click here to see highlights of the 5-1 and Greavsie’s superlative effort

But really, my question to you is Can Spurs really call it a Tottenham Hotspur Hall of Fame without Jimmy Greaves and Alan Gilzean included in it? If you tell me they can and I’m wrong it will be my last words on the subject. Vote below.

Is Spurs Hall of Fame discredited without Greaves and Gilzean?

(polls)

5 responses to “Is it a Hall of Fame without Greavsie and Gillie?

  1. Thank you so much for posting the Gilzean award speeches. I hadn’t seen these before. He comes across so well, and after some of the rumours of him turning reclusive or whatever, it was a pleasure to see him on form like that. I totally agree with your idea: he is a Spurs legend, and the club should make every effort to see he gets the recognition he deserves.

  2. I agree that Gilzean and Greaves should be inducted into the hall of fame with or without ceremony, but what about record appearance holder and most decorated of all Spurs players Steve Perryman who for me should have been one of the very first inductees….

  3. I agree wholeheartedly that they should be included and the club should accommodate their wishes for privacy/minimum fuss. Curiuosly our record appearance holder a certain Mr. Perryman is also absent from the Hall Of Fame so he along with our all time leading goalscorer are not in there!

  4. Just a minor point.
    I supported Spurs through the Greaves period and I never once heard him called “Greavsie”. I think that came either from the current Spurs web site, where everyone seems to be referred to either by initials or by adding “ie” to the end of their name, or from the TV programme with Ian St. John.
    It makes me cringe to hear it as I don’t think he was ever called that whilst a player at Spurs.

  5. Got to pull you up on that Lawrie…I too supported Spurs through that era and I can assure you that in Walthamstow he was indeed referred to as “Greavsie” with Gilzean know as “Gillie”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s